AttarCo Homes › How to Choose a Roofer
Houston Homeowner GuideThe most important decision in a roof job isn't the shingle color or even the price — it's who you hand the keys to. Texas has no state roofing license, which means the good roofers and the con artists carry the exact same business card. Here's how to tell them apart, what to ask, and the red flags that should end the conversation — from a family roofer who's answered Houston's phone since 1985.
A roof is one of the few things you buy where the quality stays hidden for years. On the day the crew drives off, a great roof and a disastrous one look identical from the street. The difference doesn't show up until the third heavy rain, the next hailstorm, or the day you try to sell — long after the check has cleared and the truck is three states away.
That's exactly why the danger peaks right after a Houston storm. Hail rakes Harris County or wind lifts shingles across Galveston, thousands of homeowners suddenly need work at once, and the market fills with out-of-town crews who followed the weather in. You're stressed, your ceiling is stained, and someone's standing on your porch with a clipboard promising to make it all go away today. That pressure — not the roof — is the real hazard. Slow down, and the decision gets a lot easier.
"Storm chaser" isn't an insult — it's a business model. Crews travel the country following hail and hurricane paths, set up a temporary presence, sign as many jobs as they can while the damage is fresh, do the work fast, and move on before anything can go wrong on the warranty. Recognize the pattern and you'll spot it from the driveway:
Not every out-of-town crew is dishonest, and being local doesn't automatically make someone good. But the playbook above is designed to get you committed before you can check anything — and anything designed to stop you from checking is worth being suspicious of. The antidote is simple: ask specific questions and verify the answers.
You don't need to be a roofing expert to vet one. Ask these six things, and how a contractor answers tells you almost everything — a legitimate one responds to all of them without flinching.
The reassuring signs are just the storm-chaser playbook turned inside out. This is what a roofer you can trust looks like.
An office you could drive to and years of work in the same market you can verify. Longevity in one place is hard to fake — it means past customers could always find them, and still can.
Current liability coverage and workers' comp, sent without you having to push. It protects you, and a contractor who carries it wants you to know.
Named manufacturer and product line, tear-off and disposal, new flashing and ventilation, per-sheet decking terms — a document you can hold them to, not a one-line number.
They inspect, document, quote, and let you gather other bids. The price is still good next week because it was honest this week.
Their own labor guarantee in writing, on top of the manufacturer's — backed by a company likely to still be around to honor it.
A roofer who tells you a repair is the smarter call — even though it's the smaller ticket — is showing you the inspection was honest.
Of every warning sign in this guide, one is not a matter of judgment or taste — it's the law. If a contractor offers to waive, absorb, pay, rebate, or "eat" your insurance deductible so the roof feels free, walk away. Since 2019, Texas law (HB 2102) makes it a crime for a contractor to do that, and your insurer can require proof that you actually paid your deductible.
Understand what's really being proposed. On an approved storm-damage claim, your out-of-pocket cost is your deductible — that's the deal you signed with your insurer. When a roofer promises to make it disappear, the money doesn't vanish; it gets buried in an inflated claim, in corners cut on your roof, or in an invoice that quietly doesn't match what the insurer was told. Either way, your name is on the claim and the fraud. It is a preview, in the very first conversation, of exactly how that company handles the parts of the job you'll never see from the ground.
The honest version is boring and that's the point: your cost is your deductible, the insurer funds the covered rest, and a reputable roofer helps you document the claim properly rather than gaming it. We've walked Houston homeowners through storm-damage insurance claims for decades, and the honest math has never needed a crime to work.
Close cousin to the deductible pitch is the paper a storm chaser most wants in your hand on the first visit: an insurance contingency agreement. It's usually presented as harmless — "just sign so we can talk to your insurance for you" — but its real job is to lock you to one contractor before you've done any comparison shopping, sometimes with a cancellation penalty if you change your mind.
You are never obligated to sign a contract to get an inspection or to have your damage documented. Take the inspection. Take the photos and the paperwork for your claim. Then take your time deciding who does the work. A roofer who can't let you sleep on it is telling you the pressure is the product.
Everything in this guide points back to one idea: a warranty is only as good as the odds the company is still here in year five. A roof's real test isn't installation day — it's the storm three years from now, the slow leak that surfaces in year four, the flashing detail that was rushed and finally gives. Most roof failures are installation failures, and they always announce themselves late.
That's the fatal flaw in choosing on price alone. The cheapest bid wins the day you sign and loses every rainy day after — especially when the number was low because the crew planned to be unreachable before the bill for their shortcuts came due. What you're actually buying, from anyone, is the confidence that someone will answer the phone and stand behind the work when it matters. A company with decades in the same market, a real address, and a name to protect has every incentive to pick up. A crew that chased the hail into town has every incentive not to.
That's the whole case for weighting a long local track record over a door-knocker's discount — and in an industry with no state license, that track record is the closest thing to a guarantee you're going to get. It's why we serve the same Houston-area counties, year after year, and put our history where you can check it.
Do roofers have to be licensed in Texas?
No — Texas has no state roofing license. Anyone can print a magnet, buy a ladder, and call themselves a roofer, which is exactly why the state's storm-chaser problem is so bad. Because a license won't protect you, the things that actually do carry more weight here: a real local address and history, current liability insurance and workers' comp you can verify, a written scope, a written workmanship warranty, and a track record long enough to check. Ask for those instead of a license number that doesn't exist.
How can I tell a storm chaser from a local roofer?
A storm chaser shows up days after a hail or wind event, knocks doors, and pushes you to sign something the same afternoon — often an out-of-state phone number, a rented truck, and a company that didn't exist in Houston last month. A local roofer has a physical address you can drive to, a history in the area you can look up, and no problem giving you time to get other bids. The simplest test: ask where their office is and how long they've worked this ZIP code, then verify it. Chasers get vague; locals get specific.
What questions should I ask a roofing contractor before hiring?
Ask for a local physical address and how long they've worked the area; a current certificate of liability insurance and workers' comp; a written scope that names the manufacturer and product line, not just "30-year shingle"; a per-sheet price for decking replaced at tear-off, with your approval required; a written workmanship warranty, in addition to the manufacturer's; and local references from jobs a year or more old. A legitimate contractor answers all of these without flinching. Vagueness on any of them is your answer.
Is it legal for a roofer to waive or pay my insurance deductible?
No — in Texas it is illegal. Since 2019, Texas law (HB 2102) makes it a crime for a contractor to waive, absorb, rebate, or offset your insurance deductible, and your insurer can require proof you actually paid it. A roofer offering a "free roof" by eating your deductible is proposing insurance fraud with your name on the claim, and it tells you how they'll treat the parts of the job you can't see. On an approved storm claim, your out-of-pocket cost is your deductible — that's the honest math, from anyone.
Should I sign an insurance contingency agreement on the first visit?
No — take the inspection and the documentation, but don't sign a contract on the first knock. A "contingency agreement" is designed to lock you to one contractor before you've gathered other bids or thought it through, and the urgency to sign it today is the sales tactic, not a real deadline. A reputable roofer will inspect your roof, document damage for your claim, and let you take your time choosing who does the work. Anyone who can't let you sleep on it is telling you something.
Why does hiring a local, long-established roofer matter so much?
Because a warranty is only as good as the odds the company is still here to honor it. Most roof failures are installation failures, and they show up years after the payment — in year three, year five, the next big storm. A crew that followed the hail into town is gone before the leak appears; the phone number is dead and the warranty is worthless. A roofer with decades in the same market, a real address, and a reputation to protect has every reason to answer the phone when it matters. That track record is the closest thing to a guarantee this unlicensed industry offers.
See what a proper job includes on our roof replacement page — or check everywhere we work →
Ask us every question on this page — we'll answer all of them. Two minutes on our quote form, or call or text (281) 686-9227, and you'll have a real written quote for your actual roof by the end of the next business day, guaranteed (often same day). Free, no pressure, and if a repair is the honest answer, that's what the quote will say.
Get My Free Quote →